Leadership Matters | Challenges and Opportunities of Leading Learning

This blog is excerpted from the Performance Matters Podcast. In this episode co-host Dr. Conrad Gottfredson sat down with Honora Whitfield, Meta’s Global Director of Learning and Katie Coates, McKinsey & Company’s Director of Learning, to discuss how they are working to shift their organization’s thinking around learning.

Conrad Gottfredson (CG): It's my honor to be joined by two of the most remarkable learning leaders on the planet. For years, I've had a front row seat to watch you both lead your learning teams and transform your organizations from a traditional learning mindset and focus, to a performance first approach.

You know, I’ve also read that about 29 to 30% of senior management roles globally are filled by women. I'm wondering what advice do you have for other women looking to grow their careers and abilities to lead learning?

Katie Coates (KC): I think what's really helped me over the years is just having the right mentors and sponsors to help guide me in the whole journey.

And I've had many. In my undergraduate I connected with a university professor who took me under her wing, she said, “You have no idea how much potential you have, right?” And she just started looking for opportunities for me. And through the years we stayed very close.

In the mid-90s I started working with another leader. He, again, just provided career guidance, opened up opportunities for me, coached me through difficult situations, and really just took a personal interest in me.

And one more, when I came to McKinsey it was a different operating model and way of working than I was used to. I met this woman that I connected with and I'm like, “hey, I need some help trying to navigate.” And she of course was happy to help. She has been someone I talk to monthly, for the past six years.  

The point is, find various types of mentors along the way and don't be afraid to ask for help. Don't be afraid to ask for someone to mentor you. People are generous.

Honora Whitfield (HW): When I think about this role, and I think about what it takes to be successful and effective in this role, I think about three dimensions.

I think about understanding and having a deep expertise in the discipline itself, I think about the leadership role and that hat that you wear, and then I think about the operational aspect of the role.

To have a chance at being an effective learning leader, I think you have to have all three of those in spades. Sharing from my career path, I've probably done each and every role within my organization over the past 25 years. And I think that has made me the leader that I am today.

Just being able to understand and have empathy for the work itself, because I’ve been in those shoes, really resonates with my team. So, my advice to others who want to be a learning leader, no matter where you are in your career, is to really gain a deep understanding and appreciation for all the depth and breadth of the work. Being a well-rounded learning leader has been my path, and it’s worked well for me.

CG: Just brilliant advice.

So, let me just share an observation that I've made about the both of you. I find that you are caring leaders. That is, you care about the people with whom you work, those that you lead, you champion them, and you are really genuine.  Katie, you talk about being lifted up, but you lift others, I just would like to know your thoughts about that element of leadership, that connectedness and the caring side.

HW: Yeah, I think it's important that I feel personally committed to caring for the whole person—not just the work side of the person, but their people, their mothers, their fathers, their families. Over the course of the pandemic we got in touch more with this personal side because we were all working from and seeing firsthand their children, their struggles, and their day-to-day lives via Zoom.

So, you really, as a leader, must focus on doing what’s best for them from both the personal and business perspectives. And when I’m mentoring individuals on my team, I'm mentoring them not for the job that they're doing today, I'm mentoring them for the job that they want to do tomorrow—whether that's on my team or on another team, whether it's in our organization or within another organization. I just find that you get the most out of people when you care for them on a personal level.

KC: I kind of look at it as my obligation to now help the next generation of learning leaders get there. So, I spend a lot of time mentoring some of my dear colleagues. In fact, I just helped one of our specialists get promoted to manager, and I'm so excited for them and for the opportunities that are ahead for them.

I've even helped people kind of figure out, do you want to stay kind of where you are? Or, do you want to look at other opportunities outside of where you are? You know, what's the right role for you, as a professional and as an individual?

So again, it's this obligation to build the next set of learning leaders, and how do I set people up for success.

CG: I have a good friend who had said to me, “You know, it's not the role of a leader to maintain the status quo.” And both of you have been challenging the status quo as it relates to learning, by moving to performance. As you've been shifting and helping your organizations move from being learning focused to a performance first focus, what are some of the barriers you have faced and some successes that you found in that journey?

KC: Yeah, so I think you know, in-person learning is still a very traditional, very loved method of learning. It really is. And our organization is no different, in-person learning meets a really big need for us in terms of community connection, celebration, transition, the leadership mindset, and it's what our people really love. And it's what they think about learning.

I think performance support, there are so many different definitions of it, and there are misconceptions about what it is, and what it can and can't do. So that's some of the things we've been kind of working through. How we’re doing it is by talking through the speed of change. You can't possibly learn everything you need to in an in-person classroom setting, you just can't right?

And so, we are trying to open up the organization to other ways of learning, such as learning in the workflow.  We found a couple leaders that are really willing to take a risk and that liked this idea. We talked to them about it, and we started with a project! We picked something that wasn't, you know, too high profile too high risk, and we're like, “let's do this, let's learn from it, experiment!”

And we did it and we had great success with that project; we learned a lot from it and it had a lot of high results. Other teams and people saw what they did, and the results that they had, and they're like, “we want that”. So, we just worked with another group to build a digital coach for a group of 3,000 people to provide consistent processes and access to learning in the flow of work.

So, I think it's that experimentation, finding the right projects, and showing success that is helping us alter the status quo.

HW: So, I think that the barrier often with implementing performance support and workflow learning is that some senior leaders have just never heard of it before. You know, “What is this Five Moments of Need thing? What is workflow learning?”

And even some of our internal team members have never heard of it before, right?

So, there's this huge change management effort that you're really embarking upon, once you sell them on the benefits, they get it, and they want it. And they want it yesterday.

It also comes with a price tag and is not something you can do it overnight. So those are other barriers, right?

How do you get the funding? How do you prove the ROI for it, once you are able to get the funding? And then it's trying to set realistic expectations on what it's going to take and how many resources you need and how much time you need before you're going to have it in place.

And you will reap the benefits of it, so I think that those are just things that you have to be really explicit about and really take the time to do and do right.

So, again, how we’re changing the status quo is by selling them on all of the benefits, setting realistic expectations, and then choosing one project at a time to implement. That's how we’ve approached it and we are focusing on basically one project per year, get it done really well, and get the adoption that we're looking for before we move on to the next solution.

For Con, Honora, and Katie’s full performance-first discussion, listen to the full episode.

Don’t forget to subscribe to The Performance Matters Podcast to stay up to date on all the latest conversations and guests in The 5 Moments space.

Copyright © 2022 by APPLY Synergies, LLC 

All Rights Reserved. 

Experience Matters | Do Something!

This blog is excerpted from the Performance Matters Podcast. In this episode host Bob Mosher sat down with Doug Holt, the Executive Directors of the Training Institute at the Council of the Inspectors General on Integrity and Efficiency (CIGIE), to talk about their approach to learning and how Doug is getting others to join the party!

Bob Mosher (BM): I am extremely excited for today's podcast as I get to spend time with a dear friend, one of my heroes in the space, and a learning leader of great stature in our area. Mr. Doug Holt. It's great to have you here. Doug, welcome.

Doug Holt (DH):  Thank you, Bob. I'm really glad to be here excited to have this chat.

BM: We’re kindred spirits around our strong feelings about the direction of L&D and that it should be all about performance. We both bang the drum around this shift—shifting away from training-first and instead putting performance-first. What was your “aha” that changed the way you view training?

DH: I vividly remember it; it was at an ATD event. And you were the presenter. This was maybe eight or nine years ago at this point, but your comments really filled in the answers to some of the major questions I was asking myself about the L&D profession as a whole. For example, “if training works, why doesn't it work?” “Why is it that we always must make a circumstantial case to demonstrate ROI, if I can use that term, instead of a direct evidence case?”

So, as you were sitting there going through your methodology and general thoughts about the L&D field, suddenly everything made sense and I think I went up to you right after and said, “Hi, I'm Doug, and I want you to come talk to us.” That was it.

BM: We did, and so the journey began. But why do you think our industry finds this shift so hard?

DH: Well, I think there are a number of factors that come into play. I'll list a few, but I'm sure there are more.

First one is we're shaped by our experiences and our collective experiences. Learners in the K through 12, or K through college model, or slight variations thereof, it's what we know. And you can look at most of what happens and see yep, that's the K through 12 model really. One of the things that I used to do at DIA when I was trying to make the point that we need to do things differently is I would put up an image of learning in the Middle Ages. It was a guy standing at a lectern talking to rows of people who were just kind of passed out because they were so bored. In my presentation I’d say, “you see much difference between this and what we do today?” And of course, the answer was always “no, it's largely the same”. In my mind, we've been doing the same thing the same way since the Middle Ages. So that's some pretty significant shaping, that would be number one.

Number two, in my experience, most people enter the learning field as a collateral duty, to fill some kind of role that they don't know much about. That's how I got into it. They learn what to do from those who preceded them, who learned from the people before them, and so on and so forth. It's sort of a hand me down, here's what I know. And I'm going to teach you what I know, there's no right way to do it. There's just lots of flavors of the month that we encounter, and people run to this one or that one. But there's no sort of central standards that people tie to, or body of research that people know about, or whatever, you know what I mean, it's just kind of like we’re all winging it.

Number three, and this is a big one—administrative convenience. It is much easier to do Monday through Friday, eight to five, I just bring you in, do the teaching thing and then turn you lose and you go back to work the next week. As opposed to, I have to figure out a way to chunk your learning to bring you in for a couple hours here, a couple hours there, maybe make some virtual kind of things. And you know, that’s really hard to do. And so, we default to the thing that we know. I also think that practical reality really does work against us in a lot of ways and that it's often hard for learners themselves to engage in ways that research might tell us they learn best.

So, it's that combination of things, and others, but it's a pretty steep hill to be pushing this rock we’re pushing up.  

BM:  Well, I think that plays perfectly into my next question. For those listening, who are going to make this pivot, what challenges lie ahead for these learning leaders and their teams who want to embark on this performance-first journey?

DH: You have to first understand that you are the outlier, you are the heretic, you're the different one and you have to get comfortable with that. I love it.

Second would be resistance and that could be from within your own team. They may not be comfortable with it; they may not understand it. You are going to get some resistance from your team and it's not personal. It is just different. Some people within the team will gravitate right to it, others will not. Then, some will be in the middle, but you have to be okay with it and work with people over time, meet them where they are and grow together until you get to a point where everything's working.

Third, unlearning and relearning. And this, I mentioned up front, that I was originally hired because I didn't know anything. And I found myself saying the other day, from here on out, I'm only hiring people who don't have a clue about anything to do with learning so that we can work with them; it's much easier to work with a blank slate. I then thought, oh my gosh, you know, I have become the person that hired me. I reflected on it, they were hiring me to do traditional things, maybe in nontraditional ways, but traditional things. And the struggle previously, or the struggle that they were fighting against, was applying traditional learning in a nontraditional format, but it was still traditional.

So, it's a lot easier to work with people who are starting from knowing nothing than it is to start from a base of people who have really worked in this field for a long time and have deeply ingrained beliefs or are simply just accustomed to doing it this way.

That brings me to another one—the ability to maintain strategic patience. This is probably the hardest of all the challenges because you run into so many delays and roadblocks and frustrations. So, it's just maintaining a view of the North Star. Therefore, this is one of those things where you want to involve everybody upfront. But the practical reality is, you can't, you have to work with a smaller team. So, then you have those folks who are in and those folks are out and managing the relationships becomes very challenging. And then when do you bring them in? You know, there's a point where you have to expand the circle here, but when and how and have you burned bridges by that point that you know, they don't want to be in your circle anymore? Because you didn't let them in at the beginning? Yep.

And then the last thing, once you've seen it, you can't unsee it. Once you've seen the flaws of the traditional and the goodness of the new. It's just going to be the thing that gets under your skin. So, if you're not prepared to have something under your skin that's pushing you forward every day and making you crazy that you haven't fixed it yet. Don't get into it, because it will absolutely do that.

BM: Perfect. So, appreciate you've always been so willing to share the good, bad, and the ugly of what you've been through. So, appreciate your candor and directness about the whole thing because like my dad always said, “there's good things in everything”. And as L&D professionals, there’s never been a better time than now for us to support performance in this way. 

For Bob and Doug’s full performance-first discussion, listen to the full episode.

Don’t forget to subscribe to The Performance Matters Podcast to stay up to date on all the latest conversations and guests in The 5 Moments space.

Copyright © 2022 by APPLY Synergies, LLC 

All Rights Reserved. 

Learning Versus Training

This blog is excerpted from the Performance Matters Podcast episode entitled “Learning v. Training” where Bob Mosher and Conrad Gottfredson discuss the transfer of true learning competency, versus training.

Bob Mosher (BM): Welcome back to another performance matters podcast episode. Today my colleague and friend, Dr. Conrad Gottfredson, and I will discuss something we’ve been struggling with as an industry—discerning true learning from training.

Conrad Gottfredson (CG): Bob, we've had a myopic view of what real learning is. For so many organizations learning is only about knowledge acquisition, or individual skill mastery. And it's all centered around making that knowledge and/or those skills stick (be retained).

When I was in graduate school, my mentor, Grant Harrison taught me that it's one thing to master all the component parts of a skill or set of skills, but at some point, learners need to integrate it all together into real performance.

So often, after training classes, learners are left to themselves to put Humpty Dumpty together—and it's tough, especially in the flow of work.

BM: Let’s be clear here, we are huge advocates of formal training. And I use that word on purpose, as vocabulary is important. We do think that the formal side of the Five Moments, and the resources we build in that domain, are truly training assets. I don't know if we think they are learning assets. I think the learning and support assets are more in the workflow.

In our own work, we always have some degree of formal learning that initiates the journey towards people becoming competent. There are clearly things that warrant and should be trained. Right. But tell us a little bit more about that jump to transfer.

CG: Well, the question that we have to ask is how are our learners integrating all that we teach into their existing experience? How are we facilitating that? How are we intentionally making that happen?

Well, right now, what happens is we throw learners over the learning fence. They finished the course, whether it's elearning, or whatever it is, and then we leave them on their own, to not only take all those pieces and put Humpty Dumpty together again, but they then must also navigate and adapt what they have learned to fit their environment, in an integrated way.

So real learning must somehow trigger past experience, bringing new experience in and integrating those experiences into a more broad experience base. Real learning is really all about experience, ultimately, experience in the flow of work. The transfer stage of learning is challenging, because we typically don't provide the support that a learner needs to become an effective performer.  Our solutions must help learners navigate that transfer stage rapidly and successfully, and recover if there are mistakes, so that they can fulfill that integration requirement and begin to perform in the workplace and learn through experience.

BM: This is why workflow analysis is so key because the workflow provides the context of transfer. This is such a fundamental shift in how we approach train, transfer, sustain. Ironically, though, train comes first in the journey of those three words, but we build from transfer and sustain back, and then training is whatever is necessary.

You know, we've got to stop thinking that our work ends at the door—whether that be a digital door of an LMS, or a concrete door of a face-to-face course. I'm probably going to get blasted for this, but I wish we'd never called it elearning, I think it's etraining.

I’m not saying “train” is a four-letter word of destruction. What we're trying to do here is for the learner, and for the journey that they are on to becoming performers. We must put our deliverables in the right place. And in the right perspective, training was never a true transfer contextualizing tool, because it does not live in the workflow. It's not used or consumed while working. And that's why this whole design of the digital coach, and distinguishing learning from training, is so important. They really do have different intents, right?

CG: You know, training and learning is a two-way street. Training is what we do. And we know there are fundamental principles that we can employ in training someone to do something and helping them understand as they do that, but then the learner has a responsibility to write learning approaches is different than training, and both have to be there. And then both trainer and learner, you know, the training efforts that we make, and the learning efforts on the learner have that work. It just can't do it all in those events. You've got to extend that through the transfer stage where you integrate newly gained experience with existing experience and develop expertise.


Listen to the full episode for more around this discussion. Then, plan to join us with your thoughts on January 19th as we continue the discussion live with both Bob and Con.

Subscribe to The Performance Matters Podcast to stay up-to-date on all the latest conversations and guests in The 5 Moments space.

You may also download our latest eBook for free here.

Copyright © 2022 by APPLY Synergies, LLC 

All Rights Reserved. 

L&D's Call to Action

 This blog is excerpted from the Performance Matters Podcast episode where Bob Mosher and Brandon Carson, Vice President of Learning and Leadership for Walmart, sat down to discuss L&D’s current responsibility in today’s world of work.

Bob Mosher (BM): Today, we are hosting yet another experience matters podcast, our most popular series, and I am honored to have a longtime friend, hero of mine, and a remarkable learning leader in our industry—Brandon Carson, vice president of learning and leadership at Walmart, join us today.

Brandon Carson (BC): Thank you, Bob. It's great to be here. Thanks for having me.

BM: Of course, and I know this will be a well listened to podcast, my friend. I don't do the bio thing, but it does helps us tell the story. So, tell us a bit about your journey in learning how you've arrived at this remarkable new role.

BC: It has been a long, strange trip. It is for all of us. I'm now a quarter century into my L&D career, and every moment has been rewarding. I fell into this accidentally. But it's been a blast, primarily just because it's about building capability. I transitioned from designing college textbooks, to interactive media, which then got me into corporate training, because we put together some, what we called interactive CD ROMs, for the books that I was helping to design.

And that's when I got the box that was on the shelf. I got the authorware box. And we worked together to build this whole CD ROM supplement for one of our top selling biology books. He built all the animations and I built the structure.

But I did get to the point where I realized I didn’t really have a programming mind. And I truly believe what Bill Gates said once about programming. He said, “either you have it, or you don't, there's not a lot of gray area there.” So, I then began to focus more on instructional design and then over time, took on more responsibility and eventually moved into learning leadership.

But I've been fortunate to really work with some great committed teams and companies over the years. I've learned so much on this journey. So, if you're lucky to have meaningful work, you've hit the jackpot. And I feel like I've won that jackpot many times over.

BM: Remarkable and I love the pivot and meaningful work. That leads me to my next question. I've seen you do many things. You just released the L&D playbook for the digital age. You are a digital advocate. You're digitally literate and you have a wonderful learning mind. And, obviously technology has, and should, play a remarkable role in L&D. But what inspired you to take on that project? And what were your learnings for our listeners?

BC: The main reason I wrote the book really comes from my feeling that our practice, the practice of corporate learning and development, we're at an inflection point. I think, and for over half a century, we've been stewards of performance. And for more than half a century, we have developed the systems, the infrastructure that's necessary to operationalize what John Hagel refers to as “scalable efficiency”. I really stress to your listeners that they look up “John Hagel, scalable efficiency”, it's a great video.

But it’s the optimization of human performance within the constraints of a replicable work system in a scalable efficiency work model that catapulted us into unheard of prosperity, and it lifted so many of us in the new economic categories.

But, as we transitioned from the industrial age to this age, the information/digital age, we have been behind the curve in evolving our work environments and our labor models. And now with the digital age, taking us into this rapid acceleration, we've seen an increase. It's amazing the speed and complexity, that we've all been going through, especially over the last couple of years.

And so fundamentally, how work gets done, has changed, and is changing so quickly. That scalable efficiency work model shows its vulnerabilities and a lot of us are seeing that over this last year and a half with these.

It’s what I like to call the great reassessment.

Some people are saying that the great resignation has people starting to reevaluate what they want from work and their labor, right? So, this is bringing more pressure to the business and the workforce.

So, L&D needs a call to action. We need to re-scope, we need to restructure, and we need to reposition and fundamentally rethink our operating model. We need to be the catalyst in this new age of work to help create that capability that we now need.

So not to sound too dramatic about it. But I hope that the book could spark a conversation within our practice about what our new opportunity is, and our new responsibility.

Candidly, I started this book before COVID. I started writing it right as COVID unleashed. And I remember Justin, my publisher, pinged me and he's like, “You want to weave in, you know, the pandemic and its impact?” And I'm like, “Sure, but it's unfolding in real time”.

So, it took a couple of months of just writing, but I was able to weave in some of what we're all looking at, L&D is all of a sudden becoming more visible, we're on center stage now because so many functions within the companies, including the CEO and C-suite folks, have come to us with heightened expectations. So that's the genesis of the book, and it's a little contrarian because it's asking those in our practice to rethink everything we're doing in our operating model.

BM: It’s definitely been a wakeup call, a remarkable opportunity, but a wakeup call. So, if I may focus a bit more on these times we’re living in, what do you think are the challenges and opportunities that L&D faces right now?

BC: Yeah, we have quite a few challenges. But candidly, we also have some great opportunities.

We've shown over the last year that we can indeed pivot our practices to lead through crisis. I mean, I was at an airline when this unfolded, and I wouldn't recommend that to anyone, for some odd reason, during a pandemic, people don't want to get in a metal tube really close together for some strange reason. But that was a year of leading through crisis, you know, and we had to pivot to focus more on ensuring business continuity.

And we at the airline, we had a heightened visibility just like you're talking about because we had to ensure that business continuity, we were an essential service to the nation, right? And none of us had a playbook for this pandemic, but as I've talked to colleagues across many industries, I've repeatedly heard stories about how L&D kicked in to provide programs, resources, and tools to keep the workforce going and keep the customer safe. We rapidly transition to training modalities. I mean, all of us were doing virtual overnight, practically. And we do a lot of on-the-job training in the airline. And so that was a challenge. How do we position that because we couldn't be close together. So, I would say in February 2020, not one CEO was thinking that they’d have an entirely distributed work team, and in 30 days, almost every company was figuring out how to work in a distributed manner, but also how to empower the workforce to work differently.

It's an amazing representation of people coming together and leveraging technology and new processes to keep the world operating. I mean, that's really what happened. And L&D was a key component in that.

But as we move forward, we now face a complete rethinking of work itself. And we're kind of in the middle of this conversation. After almost two years of new ways of working people are questioning and feeling empowered to engage in conversations about how they want to work moving forward. And so, I like to call this the great reassessment because we're pausing and reflecting on work and everyone's having these conversations, with HR and L&D being the catalyst.

And so, in a lot of ways, it's going to end up being the great reawakening as well. We’ll look back and say, “We had a once in a century global pandemic, you know, at least we hope so, it interrupted our value systems, it interrupted our work models and, we were great because we showed what humanity is able to do.”

BM: This is this is a brave new world for us.

Listen to the full episode for more from Brandon around the 5 Moments of Need framework and how it integrates and aligns with his book and L&D’s current call to action.

Subscribe to The Performance Matters Podcast to stay up-to-date on all the latest conversations and guests in The 5 Moments space.

You may also download our latest eBook for free here.

Copyright © 2022 by APPLY Synergies, LLC 

All Rights Reserved. 

The 5 Fundamentals of Workflow Learning

This blog is excerpted from the Performance Matters Podcast episode where Bob and co-host, Conrad Gottfredson, discuss the five principles of workflow learning that they feel allows this approach to stand apart from the training-first mindset and methodology.  

Bob Mosher (BM): Welcome back to yet another Performance Matters podcast episode. Today, I am honored to be joined by co-host, Dr. Con Gottfredson to pull out the five fundamental discussion areas, principles, and themes that distinguish workflow learning.

These can be used for when you're standing in front of those you serve and say, “Look, we really should shift to the Five Moments of Need approach, or workflow learning, as a way in which we fundamentally design and work here.”

This is the list you can pull out to separate what you want to do—from the training-first mindset.

Con Gottfredson (CG): Yes, these principles also inform how we look at technology to support workflow learning; they inform everything that we do with workflow learning.

Bob Mosher (BM): Absolutely. So, let's start at what is probably the most fundamental difference, and that is the mindset shift; it really impacts the focus of our deliverables. We talk about a performance-first mindset, Con, you are the man, do you want to give us a quick overview?

CG: When I entered the real world of work out of graduate school, I had a training mindset, it was all about building a training solution, but what I found in the real world was that it was all about performance. At that time, I read a book that influenced me, it was all about analyzing performance problems and it triggered this idea that, you know, we ought to be thinking about performance. Because ultimately, Bob, at the end of the day, if people can't perform in the workplace, what have we done? I mean, what has our solution brought? And how is it contributed to the organization?

BM: Exactly. So, the 5 Moments of Need, give them to us.

CG: Well, there's the moment of apply, that's the big moment. And then within apply, there's the moment of change and the moment of solve, which are very unique at the moment of apply and require some unique treatment. And then there's the moment of learning new, which we have always worked with, and the moment of learning more. And there's a difference between those two, learning more is when I have a lot of contextual experience so I can move to learning more and more quickly with the help of performance support. Most L&D folks start with the learn new and learn more side of things, rather than the moment of apply and then cascade that to the level of change and solve.

BM: And by starting with learn new and more, that gives us that training mindset and predisposes us to a training deliverable.

CG: You know, at one point in my transition from a learning mindset to a performance mindset, I asked an important question, “Training and instruction is a means to what end? What is it that I do? What do I deliver to the organization?” And if it's not effective performance in the flow of work, which requires knowledge, certainly, but that knowledge has to be acted upon for organizations to be able to do their job. Then what are we doing?

BM: Expertly said, and we hear this all the time, "I'm sick of being an order taker. I wish I was seen more strategically in the organization; I wish I could get a seat at the table." Well, here's the thing, if you're an order taker, what's on your menu? If people only know you for training then they are going to walk in your office and say, “I want five days of training on leadership.” They're not going to walk in your offices and say, "We have a leadership issue and I want to talk to you as a partner about how we better enable leaders in this company. And then from there, we'll figure out the deliverable.”

This is the fundamental shift to performance-first and being seen as a performance-first enabling organization versus acting, or seeming like, a service organization that delivers a product called training.

CG: I once introduced myself as a performance engineer. I was tired of being viewed as a trainer.

Just think what would happen if the leadership of an organization looked to us to help them solve the challenges of effective performance in the flow of work?

BM: Well, that takes us to our second principle, we have to analyze something very different, we have to start at the moment of apply, not new and more.

And to understand apply, you have to do this remarkable thing, that transformed my design, called rapid workflow analysis. Here is where we understand what the true workflow of a leader, a manager, a frontline worker, etc. is and does. This analysis does a remarkable thing for organizations, it makes the workflow transparent. Let's talk a little bit more about that.

CG: Well, many years ago, I was involved in some major organizational transformations. And I participated in these work process redesigns. What I found was that the methodology didn't take, it didn’t move down to the tactical level of work. They were mapping workflow processes at such a high-level and really were blind to the tactical work they were doing.

Many leaders are blind, they are really blind to that work. And the minute that we open that up, and really identify what they do, it's this awakening, right? They go, "Yeah, that is what I do!" and we're able to have conversations around, “Should you really be doing that?”

And as you’ll recall, we've had many of those moments where a leader will respond to that a-ha moment with, "I don't want you doing that, I want you to be doing this." Well, how do you do that if you can't see the workflow for what it truly is?

And maybe even more importantly, when the learner finishes a training course they have to be able to then step into their work. And if that training isn't aligned to the workflow, then it's going to be tough to make that transition.

BM: Notice in these first two principles Con, we still haven't discussed a deliverable. We're still trying to figure that out. And we're not using the words “course”, “trainer”, or even “digital coach” at this point, because we just don't know.

Now, principle number three, there has always been this journey called train, transfer, sustain. But what this shift to workflow learning design through the five moments does, is it dramatically shifts that journey. So, let's step back and review the original journey. Do you want to walk us through those three stages and how they historically have been treated?

CG: Yeah, well, we do the train thing well. I mean, that's where we spend our time, in the training, and then we say, “Thank you for coming and thank you for the scores on this evaluation.” The learner then leaves that rich training experience and must figure out, “How do I apply this to my work?” That's called transfer. How do I take this and move this into my own world?

So, they most likely will fight their way through, and figure it out, because they’ve got to perform, right? And then once they get there, they have to sustain it in a world that changes and is always changing.

So, with the old model, we just throw them over the fence. We kiss him goodbye, and thank them for coming and, and then they move into the real world unprepared to transfer and manage the sustainment of that on their own with little to no formal guidance.

BM: So, what we've learned Con is that no matter what design approach you apply, including the five moments workflow learning design, those three stages of the journey are always there.

But when you focus on performance-first, we find three remarkable things happen over and over and over. Training, on average, is reduced by half. If you shift to an apply first design approach you don't have to train everything; it's not the responsibility of the trainer to wake up every day and feel the burden of having to teach everything. So, on average, we see training reduced by half.

The more important thing is that we're in the business of competency, like you said earlier, if in the end, people can't perform better, we have not done our job. In the performance-first design we see time to competency reduced on average by half because it is an enablement model. It is a journey of transfer and sustain, not a “dump model” which is what the training-first mindset tends to be.

CG: Yeah.

I had heart surgery a couple of years ago. And my first question to that heart surgeon was, how much experience have you and the team had, and how successful has that experience been? I wasn't interested in his training; I wanted to know how competent the team was.

And that time to competency is what is really important for all organizations.

Listen to the full episode for the remaining two fundamental principles of workflow learning in the 5 Moments of Need, and subscribe to The Performance Matters Podcast to stay up-to-date on all the latest conversations and guests in The 5 Moments space.

You may also download our latest eBook for free here.

Copyright © 2022 by APPLY Synergies, LLC 

All Rights Reserved.